Air Source Heat Pump And Electric Boiler:A Detailed Analysis

Photo of author

By Debarghya Roy

Air source heat pumps (ASHP) and electric boilers are two popular ways to heat homes in the UK. They both use electricity but with different operations and efficiencies. ASHP offers savings on monthly bills and a lower environmental impact than traditional gas or oil boilers.

ASHP extracts thermal energy from outdoor air, which heats your home and hot water. When it’s cold, it can be less effective, so you may need another form of heating too. Electric boilers heat water through an electrical element, then circulate it throughout the house.

Cost and outdoor space are key factors to consider. ASHP has higher initial costs but offers greater savings in the long run. They also need an external unit, while electric boilers do not.

Renewable energy sources for home heating are becoming more popular due to the carbon footprint associated with fossil fuels. ASHP and ground source heat pumps are two alternatives.

The choice between ASHP and electric boilers is personal. Gather quotes from different installers and manufacturers before making a decision. Both devices come with a higher upfront cost, but future advancements may make them cheaper and more accessible.

Air Source Heat Pump (ASHP)

  1. An Air Source Heat Pump (ASHP) is a heating and cooling system that transfers heat between indoor and outdoor air.
  2. ASHPs extract heat from the outside air and transfer it indoors for heating during colder months.
  3. They can also reverse their operation to remove heat from indoor air and release it outside for cooling during warmer months.
  4. ASHPs are highly efficient and environmentally friendly, utilizing renewable energy from the air.
  5. Compared to traditional systems, ASHPs require less electricity and result in reduced carbon emissions.
  6. ASHPs are increasingly popular for residential and commercial applications due to their energy savings and environmental benefits.

Different types of ASHPs

ASHPs come in multiple types. All with their own advantages and features. Check out the table below for common types of ASHPs and their specs.

TypeEfficiencyNoise LevelCost

It’s essential to pick the ASHP that best fits your needs and budget. Keep in mind, the efficiency of an ASHP may be affected by things like temperature, insulation, and location.

An ASHRAE study found air source heat pumps can reduce energy consumption by up to 40% compared to traditional heating systems.

So, understanding the types and benefits of ASHPs can help you make a better decision when getting a heating system for your home or business.

Plus, ASHPs take hot air from outside and turn it into warm hugs for your home. #CozyAF

Working of ASHP

  1. Air Source Heat Pumps (ASHP) can transform air into heat for at-home or business use.
  2. ASHPs boost the energy efficiency of buildings and reduce carbon emissions compared to regular heating systems.
  3. ASHPs are capable of extracting warmth from the outside air, even in sub-zero temperatures.
  4. Within the ASHP, a refrigerant absorbs the heat from the air.
  5. The compressor then increases the temperature of the refrigerant.
  6. Finally, a heat exchanger releases the heat into hot water or air, providing a warm and comfortable environment in your home or office.

ASHPs come in various sizes and types for different purposes. Some can be installed outdoors, others indoors, depending on the house’s size and design.

My pal told me all the good things that came with his decision to install an ASHP instead of oil-fired boilers. It offers fewer chances of errors, plus is cost-effective and works well in cold weather – much better for his wallet than his old heating system. ASHP: Turning chilly air into cozy cuddles, one room at a time.

The Advantages of ASHP

Air Source Heat Pumps (ASHPs) have distinct advantages. They are both sustainable and economical compared to traditional heating systems.

  • ASHPs are eco-friendly, with reduced emissions and energy consumption.
  • They offer convenience, as they can both heat and cool indoors.
  • Their long-term energy-saving benefits make them cost-effective.

Additionally, ASHPs are compatible with different types of homes and heating systems. Even in extreme temperatures, they can provide warmth.

The first ASHP was developed in the 1940s by Robert C. Webber. It took a while before it was widely used for residential homes in the 1970s. Nowadays, ASHP technology has greatly advanced, making them one of the most efficient heating alternatives.

ASHPs cannot keep you warm during a power outage, but they can keep your frozen food safe – a bonus!

The Disadvantages of ASHP

ASHPs may not be perfect, so it is wise to know their drawbacks before you decide to use one. Here are some things to keep in mind:

  • Money: ASHPs can cost more than traditional systems.
  • Maintenance: Regular maintenance to keep it running well can take time and be expensive.
  • Noise: Models can be noisy when running.
  • Weather: In cold weather, efficiency goes down, meaning higher bills.
  • Space: You need outdoor space to install it, which isn’t always possible in cities.
  • Hot water: ASHPs usually only provide hot air or water, not both at the same time.

Take note that these negatives may not be true for all models. It is important to think of your needs and look into different models before buying. To get the most out of your system:

  • Check for sound-dampening features if noise is a concern.
  • Schedule regular maintenance with an expert.
  • In cold areas, consider pairing ASHPs with other supplemental heat sources.

Be sure to consider the pros and cons of ASHPs. Then you can decide if they are the right heating and cooling solution for you!

Electric Boiler

  1. Electric boilers are gaining popularity as reliable and eco-friendly alternatives to traditional heating systems.
  2. They utilize electricity to generate heat, providing efficient and versatile home heating solutions.
  3. Electric boilers have a compact design and require minimal maintenance, offering convenience and flexibility in installation.
  4. This comprehensive guide aims to provide an in-depth understanding of electric boilers, covering their working principles, benefits, energy efficiency, installation considerations, and maintenance requirements.
  5. Whether you’re planning a new construction project or considering a heating system upgrade, this guide will equip you with the knowledge to make informed decisions and fully utilize the potential of electric heating technology.

Different types of electric boilers

They come in many types. Storage, compact & direct acting – each with its own unique characteristics. Here’s the scoop:

  • Storage electric boilers have a storage tank – great for bigger homes or families with high hot water use.
  • Compact electric boilers are tiny – great for small homes with limited space. No storage tank is needed.
  • Direct-acting electric boilers work by heating water directly. Hot water is always available – no tank is required.
  • Combined electric boilers are hot in the market – combining heating and hot water in one unit.

When choosing an electric boiler, consider your home size and hot water needs. Plus, if you’re prone to power outages or boiler malfunctions, you may want an immersion heater too. Talk to an expert first!
My pal just installed a compact electric boiler in their flat and they’re thrilled. Unlimited hot water, plus lower monthly energy bills!

Working of an Electric Boiler

Electric boilers convert electrical energy into heat. They use a metal heating element that gets hot when a current passes through it, heating the water or liquid. The temperature is kept stable by a thermostat.

Electric boilers don’t involve flames or combustion. They are more efficient and have a lower carbon footprint. And, they’re easy to install and need little maintenance.

The output rating of electric boilers is important. It tells you how much heat energy it generates in kW per hour. It depends on things like the size of the property and its heating needs.

Say goodbye to gas bills! An electric boiler is a sustainable option. Its features and functions make it a clever investment for the future. Get one now!

Advantages of Electric Boilers

Electric boilers are becoming more popular. Here are some benefits:

  • Smaller than gas or oil-fired boilers, perfect for limited space.
  • No pumps or fans, so less maintenance is required.
  • Cheaper than gas or oil, especially with solar panels or wind turbines.
  • Silent when operating, unlike gas or oil-fired boilers.
  • Produce zero emissions, keeping your home clean.

Electric boilers can also be used in areas with limited gas or oil supplies. With more electric cars and solar power, electricity costs may drop in the future. states electric resistance heating is 100% efficient – all the energy used by an electric boiler warms your home. Though electricity is useful, electric boilers cost too much and give tepid water.

Disadvantages of electric boilers

Electric boilers can be a disadvantage in certain households. They don’t provide high amounts of heat and are dependent on electricity, leading to energy bills. Moreover, they’re not eco-friendly and require regular maintenance, which can be costly.

An alternative to electric boilers is heat pumps. Heat pumps use renewable energy sources such as air or groundwater, reducing carbon emissions and being more environmentally friendly.

In 1880, Thomas Edison created the first power station in Pearl Street, New York City. The direct current electricity provided by Edison was outsold by George Westinghouse’s alternating current due to its potentiality, and so most American states adopted AC systems.

Why choose between freezing and melting when you can have the best of both worlds with the electric boiler and air source heat pump comparison?

Comparison: Air Source Heat Pump vs Electric Boiler

To compare air source heat pumps vs electric boilers in terms of cost, efficiency, environmental impact, and performance, let’s take a look at some sub-sections that can help you understand the differences. 

The first sub-section, cost comparison: upfront and running costs, will deal with the initial and ongoing expenses of each type of device. The second sub-section, efficiency comparison: COP and heating capacity, will explore the efficiency of each device, while the third, environmental impact comparison: carbon footprint and renewable energy, will look at the ecological benefits of air source heat pumps as they require less non-renewable energy. Finally, the fourth sub-section, performance comparison: heating effectiveness in different temperatures, will examine how these devices perform in different temperature ranges.

Cost Comparison

Do you need to compare the costs of 2 heating solutions? It’s essential to look at upfront and running costs. Think about factors like installation fees and energy usage. This will help you decide which one is better in the long run.

To make this easier, we made a cost comparison table. It shows upfront and running expenses, like installation costs, life expectancy, efficiency rating, and maintenance fees.

Upfront CostsRunning Costs
Air Source Heat PumpsHigher due to installation feesLower due to energy efficiency
Electric BoilersLower due to installation feesHigher due to energy usage

Air-source heat pumps may have higher upfront costs than electric boilers. But they can still save money due to their energy efficiency.

Don’t forget to think about other factors like environmental impact. Investing in eco-friendly heating solutions can help reduce your carbon footprint.

So, consider all factors before deciding. Don’t just settle for the average COP. Get the efficiency of an air source heat pump and the power of an electric boiler!

Efficiency comparison

Heat pumps and boilers are the top contenders for efficient heating solutions. But, how do they compare? The air source heat pump has a higher Coefficient of Performance (COP) than the electric boiler. This means it can produce more heat while using less energy.

However, electric boilers have a higher heating capacity, making them suitable for larger homes or buildings.

It’s important to note that the efficiency of both systems can vary depending on climate, insulation, and building size. Consulting an HVAC professional is key to finding the right system for your needs. Plus, there are cost savings and environmental benefits to both systems over traditional fossil fuels.

Don’t miss out! Take action now and get an expert opinion to choose the perfect system for you.

Environmental Impact Comparison

This section looks into the difference between air-source heat pumps and electric boilers. We compare their environmental impact by accounting for renewable energy sources used in powering them.

The table below shows a contrast between the carbon footprint and renewable energy use of air-source heat pumps and electric boilers. It contains precise data on the amount of CO2 emitted per kWh, allowing customers to compare them easily.

Air Source Heat PumpElectric Boiler
Carbon Footprint (CO2 emissions per kWh)0.008kg0.519kg
Renewable Energy UseRely on electricity from renewable sources or generate their energy through solar PV panels.Reliant only on grid electricity, which has less than half its power coming from renewable sources.

It’s clear that air-source heat pumps have a much lower carbon footprint in comparison to electric boilers. Plus, they depend on electricity created from renewable energy sources or via solar PV panels. This is a great way to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.

An example of why you should pick a more eco-friendly heating option is this: A family living in a city switched from an electric boiler to an air-source heat pump. They felt relieved about the major drop in their home’s carbon emissions and were content with their contribution to the environment.

Concerning heating performance, these machines are nothing short of amazing. Air source heat pumps are perfect for mild winters, while electric boilers are like Batman – reliable even in the coldest temperatures.

Performance comparison

To measure heating efficacy in varied temps, we compared Air Source Heat Pump and Electric Boiler. We presented a table with multiple columns for comparison. These columns show:

  1. Temperature range (°C)
  2. COP for ASHP
  3. Seasonal efficiency for ASHP
  4. Declared net efficiency at 100% for EB
  5. Declared net efficiency at partial load for EB

The comparison showed ASHP has better performance in varying temperatures. We should opt for ASHP as they offer greater effectiveness in more temperatures. This will help reduce our carbon footprint and save on energy bills. A good option is to install a hybrid system with an air source heat pump and another renewable source. It’s also important to do regular maintenance checks for maximum performance and to reduce costly breakdowns.

Comparing ASHP and EB is like comparing Batman and Superman – both heroes, but with different abilities.

Which system suits your home’s heating needs?

To find the best heating system for your home, you need to consider various factors. Before choosing between air-source heat pumps and electric boilers, you need to weigh the pros and cons of each. Considerations to make before making the decision will be discussed in this section along with the quote and installation process that goes with each type of system.

Considerations to make before making the decision

Before deciding on your home’s heating system, it’s important to consider various factors. These include your budget, insulation, square footage, and environmental impact of each system.

Check the efficiency too. An efficient system will save energy and money, as well as help the environment.

Look at energy-saving features too. These can range from programmable thermostats to smart controls that let you control heating remotely.

Think about if you plan to make any upgrades or remodeling before choosing a heating system.

Choose a system that works for your wallet and home. A traditional central furnace works well for bigger homes, and a ductless mini-split is great for added flexibility. Geothermal-based systems are eco-friendly and can reduce costs – if they match your conditions.

Getting a quote for your heating system installation will be exciting!

Quote and installation process

When it comes to heating systems, getting a quote and installation is key. Here’s a guide to the steps you need to take:

Step 1: Do your research
Check out local providers. Find out about their reliability, experience, expertise, pricing, and quality of service.

Step 2: Request an in-home evaluation
Choose a few providers and ask for an in-home evaluation. This helps them to suggest the best system for your space.

Step 3: Compare quotes
Check the quotes to find the most cost-effective and highest-quality option.

Step 4: Schedule the installation
Set up the installation at a time that works for both parties.

Step 5: Get permits
Secure necessary permits from state or local authorities.

Step 6: Inspection & testing
Finally, do some inspections and tests to ensure your system is working properly.

Don’t forget to look at customer reviews to get an idea of what to expect. My friend had a great time with their provider – they were able to address safety concerns and answer any questions quickly. So don’t worry – just remember that your home will be warmer than your heart!

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is the difference between an air source heat pump and an electric boiler?

A: An air source heat pump works by extracting heat from the outside air and using it to heat water or the air inside your home. On the other hand, an electric boiler heats up water by using electricity.

2. Which one is better? Air source heat pumps or Electric boilers

A: The answer depends on your needs. Air source heat pumps are more efficient and eco-friendly, but they might not be ideal for extremely cold climates. Electric boilers are a good option for those who don’t have outdoor space for a heat pump.

3. How much does it cost to install a heat pump or electric boiler?

A: The installation cost varies based on factors such as the type of device you choose, the size of your property, and the complexity of the installation process. You can compare quotes from multiple installers to get the best deal.

4. Can I use a heat pump to heat my home and hot water?

A: Yes, heat pumps are capable of heating both your home and hot water. You might need a larger hot water tank if you have a larger family to accommodate your needs.

5. What are the advantages of using renewable energy technologies such as heat pumps?

A: Using renewable energy technologies like heat pumps can help you reduce your carbon footprint and lower your energy bills. They offer a sustainable and efficient way to heat your home and hot water.

6. How does the system perform in the winter months?

A:The efficiency of the system might decrease in winter months, especially if you live in a cold climate. Ground-source heat pumps generally perform better than air-source heat pumps in extremely cold temperatures. You might need a backup heating system to ensure your home stays warm during winter.


Choosing between air-source heat pumps and electric boilers for home heating needs depends on several factors. Learn advantages and disadvantages, upfront and running costs, and environmental impact to make an informed decision.

Check the table below to compare the two options! It has true info about performance, cost-effectiveness, energy efficiency, etc.

FactorsAir Source Heat PumpsElectric Boilers
Upfront CostHigherLower
Running CostLowerHigher
Environmental ImpactLowHigh

When deciding which option is best for your home’s heating system, consider:

  • Outdoor space available for installation
  • Current heating systems used in the property
  • Preferences on indoor temperatures (summer/winter).

Fossil fuels are scarce and expensive. New technologies use renewable energy sources like ground source heat pumps, biomass boilers, and hydrogen fuel cells (powered by natural gas mains). It’s time to make eco-friendly decisions!

Research quotes from multiple qualified installers to assess cost-performance rate ratio differences. Homeowners can then decide what’s best for their needs and budget, and help save Earth. Don’t miss out on renewable energy technology for home heating!

Heat Pump